By Robert Pidgeon · Design & Commercial Manager, J Dunton Associates
Design peer reviews are a period spent, typically by a third party, reviewing a set of design deliverables. These assessments are often requested by major stakeholders of a project, for the reason of assessing risk from a design perspective. This could be for tendering purposes, assessing operational risks for a customer or simply understanding exploring opportunities for the client to value engineer parts of the project. In doing so and rather ironically, money is spent to complete an assessment via the third party to assess this value.
The results of a peer review will highlight non-conformances or areas of improvement aiming to reduce the lifetime cost of a project and, in cases where major risks are found, the relatively small investment of a peer review is a mere drop in the ocean as compared to costly retrospective fixes that may be required in the future.
In simple terms, one operates as the examiner ‘marking’ peoples work to see how accurate it is, or in the case of engineering where there are multitudes of ways to do things, assessing if a party has completed a design in the most effective way.
Peer reviews are typically conducted over several weeks followed by workshops and discussions for how the design will move forward.
How do we add value?
The focus of JDA will always be the specific goals that the client wants to achieve, varying for each client, stakeholder and customer, with a bespoke approach to each project. Value is added by concisely compiling items discovered within the review for client review. Items found are typically ranked from high to low priority to form the basis of future discussion.
Crucially, value isn’t just found in the form of highlighting problems …no no no. JDA are here to find opportunities be it in the form of CAPEX and OPEX savings, or if working for a contractor, this could be finding elements of the design that can be done to value engineer or compress the programme. Time is money, and value can be found by buying float in the programme via improving the effectiveness of design solutions.
How do you approach a peer review?
With an open mindset. With this type of project, ego and reputation is to be put aside. One of the brilliant parts of a peer review is approaching the design with fresh eyes and without the chains of pressured delivery timescales, tunnel visioned approaches and design preference biases. You can come to the table with differing ideas. It can be easy to criticise another consultancy for their approach however we do recognise that there are often many solutions to the same problem: Peer Reviews present a rare opportunity to work with fellow industry professionals in a non-competitive environment.
Collaboration, Collaboration, Collaboration
Once differing ideas come to the table, there is always a risk that the previous designer feels this is a personal attack on their efforts and design – I know that I certainly find it difficult for someone to criticise a project I have worked on hard! On the contrary, JDA will always take a collaborative approach in view of that bigger picture in supporting delivery of an improved product for the client. That collaborative approach does not include ‘picking on people’, it’s about providing support and asking questions in a constructive manner and importantly thinking outside of the box. Asking those questions is typically done to better understand the logic and reasoning for decisions made. And hey, we all may learn something along the way.
Following the collaboration between stakeholders, it’s not set in stone that all of comments will be incorporated into the design and, at the end of the day, we would not expect them to, however we will always ensure that the critical items are focussed upon for a quick resolution.
Like in a rowing boat, everyone needs to work in tandem; being crabby (crabbing) never helps the team
Why Choose JDA?
We have a large range of expertise, not just limited to MEP and operate in a variety of regions; working remotely allows us to collaborate with colleagues worldwide. As an agile company, we support clients on bespoke ‘fact finding and diagnosis’ and Single Point Of Failure (SPOF) projects all the way up to RIBA Stage 1-5 at a scale in the 100’s MW, always with a positive and multi-disciplinary approach.
P.S. I know Hugh Francis said in his article “Having a Data Centre as a Neighbour”, to send pictures of your dog’s stating “we” like them. I (Robert Pidgeon) put “we” in quotes as I am not a massive dog fan however I am heavily outnumbered… normally by dogs in our office.
P.P.S. (Still send dog photos)
P.P.P.S. If you want to have a chat, please get in touch!